- Written by: Benjamin Percy
- Art by: Jose Luis Soares, Oren Junior
- Colors by: Frank D’Armata
- Letters by: VC’s Cory Petit
- Cover art by: David Marquez, GURU-eFX (cover A)
- Cover price: $5.99
- Release date: February 26, 2025
The Punisher #1 (Marvel, 2/25/26): Writer Benjamin Percy and artist Jos Luis Soares deliver Frank Castle’s shadowed return to New York streets, confronting muggers and old ally Microchip amid brain fog from past control, in gritty a vigilante tale. Kinetic execution packs dramatic punch yet clings too tightly to Red Band miniseries threads; Verdict: Worth reading for Punisher fans.
First Impressions
Frank Castle stalks those familiar grimy alleys again, skull gleaming under streetlights, and it hits like a solid gut punch of classic Punisher vibe. The panels pull you right into his fractured headspace, instincts firing amid the rot and broken glass, feeling raw and lived-in from the jump. That opening sequence lingers in dark corners and builds a tense, almost nostalgic pull, even as nagging ties to prior events whisper this might not stand fully alone.
Yet something nags beneath the surface. The dramatic beats land with brutal weight, evoking peak vigilante form, but those heavy plot strings from Red Band pull the momentum sideways just enough to notice. It promises a return to form while leaning on yesterday’s wounds a bit too comfortably.
Recap
Frank Castle returns to New York City as his own man once more after serving as a mind-controlled hitman, though the details of his comeback remain a mystery even to him; he holds his old ally Microchip accountable for aiding in that manipulation.
Plot Analysis (SPOILERS)
Frank Castle drifts through New York’s underbelly like a shadow, drawn to subways, fire escapes, and trash-strewn alleys without clear purpose, his mind a bruised fog piecing together identity. A green-haired thug pulls a gun demanding his pockets emptied, but Frank dispatches him coldly, stepping over broken glass and decay as if belonging among the filth. Police chatter fills the air with slashed tires, fires, and disturbances, underscoring the city’s chaos he navigates instinctively.
He stops a robbery at Chan’s Bodega in Chinatown, boot crushing a robber’s hand, grabbing the loot bag before casually asking the terrified shopkeeper for a chocolate bar’s price, taking it free amid the fear. Driving off in a van, agony grips his chest, his body rebelling as the vehicle crashes into a wall, punishing him from within. Meanwhile, at WNEX headquarters, reporter Madeline pushes a Punisher comeback story, dismissed by her boss fixated on superhuman spectacles over street-level grit.
In a dim room, Frank confronts bearded Microchip at gunpoint, history heavy between them as Microchip pleads he saved him, accepting a chocolate bar with desperate relief. Frank demands Microchip fix something wrong in his brain, hinting at deeper manipulation scars. Across town at Rikers, a shadowed figure in a prison cell reveals himself to Tombstone as Jigsaw, back from near-death with grand plans.
Jigsaw recounts his climb from poverty to hitman setbacks, vowing this time to unite gangs under his big-picture vision as boss of bosses, forcing Tombstone to sign over assets by threatening family. He eyes the power vacuum left by fallen foes, fixating on flushing out the returning Punisher to claim New York fully. Frank, Micro, and Jigsaw’s paths simmer toward collision, instincts and ambitions driving the night forward.
Writing
Pacing slices through scenes with brutal economy, propelling Frank’s wanderings and clashes forward without a wasted panel, building dread through caption-driven introspection that mirrors his fractured psyche effectively. Dialogue snaps authentic in raw exchanges, from the mugger’s cocky demands to Microchip’s pleading history, laced with street grit that feels pulled from real underbelly tension. Structure layers personal torment atop citywide disorder smartly, thematic depth emerging in compulsions versus choice, though Red Band echoes disrupt the standalone punch a #1 demands.
Exposition weaves via captions and sparse talks without stilted dumps, keeping momentum kinetic even in quieter beats like the bodega payoff. Yet those prior miniseries ties surface too prominently in Micro’s plea and brain-fix plea, prioritizing continuity over fresh hooks that could stand alone bolder. Overall, Percy’s command crafts a compelling vigilante pulse, sharp yet occasionally handcuffed by baggage.
Art
Layouts flow with streetwise precision, guiding the eye through dynamic low angles on the mugger standoff and wide alley vistas that amplify isolation, clarity shining in every shadowed corner. Character acting sells Frank’s stoic menace through subtle posture shifts and unyielding stares, while Micro’s tearful desperation registers viscerally in close facial beats. Color tonality bathes panels in sickly greens and stark sodium glows, moodily reinforcing decay and inner rot without overpowering the inks.
Composition synergizes with action bursts, like boot-on-hand crunch and van crash sparks exploding off page edges for visceral impact. Inker Oren Junior’s lines add gritty texture to urban filth, from syringes to rotting carcasses, heightening immersion. Soares’ style captures Hells Kitchen authenticity post-Daredevil, though occasional crowd scenes blur slightly under heavy shadows.
Character Development
Frank’s motivations pulse through instinctual violence and self-doubt, consistent in his merciless efficiency yet relatable in vulnerable crashes revealing human fragility beneath the skull. Microchip evokes conflicted loyalty, his history with Frank adding layers without overexplaining. Jigsaw bursts with ambitious menace, near-death reflection fueling consistent drive toward empire, making him a fresh threat grounded in personal evolution.
Originality & Concept Execution
The premise refreshes Punisher’s street war via brain-trauma haze and power vacuums, delivering gritty execution that nails classic vigilante isolation amid chaos. Success shines in dramatic skirmishes evoking peak form, but heavy Red Band reliance on mind-control aftermath and Micro ties undermines #1 freshness, chaining the concept to miniseries threads instead of bold independence.
Pros and Cons
What We Loved
- Brilliantly paced captions mirror Frank’s fractured psyche, heightening dread.
- Kinetic inks and low angles amplify visceral action tension flawlessly.
- Jigsaw’s big-picture monologue delivers chilling, authentic villain ascent.
Room for Improvement
- Red Band plot ties overload #1, stifling standalone fresh start.
- Brain fog exposition leans too heavily on prior miniseries baggage.
- Minor crowd compositions blur under dense shadow layering.
About The Reviewer: Gabriel Hernandez is the Publisher & EIC of ComicalOpinions.com, a comics review site dedicated to indie, small, and mid-sized publishers.Follow @ComicalOpinions on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter
The Scorecard
Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): 3/4
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): 3/4
Value (Originality & Entertainment): 1/2
Final Verdict
The Punisher #1 delivers dramatic wallops and a welcome return to skull-clad classics, Frank’s instincts carving through grime with fierce precision that earns cheers from vigilante diehards. Yet those insistent Red Band plot shackles hobble what should soar as a clean #1 launch, demanding readers carry miniseries weight into supposed new ground. In a tight pull list, it claims space for raw Punisher thrills if you savor the form, but skips await those craving unburdened beginnings.
7/10
We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media:
Connect With Us Here: Weird Science DC Comics / Weird Science Marvel Comics
If you’re interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.
Click here to find your Local Comic Shop: www.ComicShopLocator.com
As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.
Weird Science Marvel Comics 